
For nearly 24 hours, businesses around the world couldn’t:
- Send or receive emails in Outlook;
- Manage their calendars;
- Hold Teams calls and meetings;
- Access shared files on SharePoint; or
- Use Microsoft’s Copilot AI assistant.
Some businesses also reported problems opening Word and Excel files. Microsoft has described it as one of the longest disruptions in its history.
The ratings agency Morningstar DBRS has estimated global insured losses at between $300 million and $500 million. Microsoft services are heavily intergreated into most businesses’ day to day operations. Here in the UK, some NHS services went back to paper records. For many businesses, it meant a lost day of trading, missed deadlines and some difficult conversations with customers.
Now that systems are back up, a lot of business owners are asking the same question: can we get any of that money back, and if so, from who?
Can You Claim From Microsoft?
In short, probably not much. Microsoft 365 agreements offer “service credits” when availability falls below the levels set out in Microsoft’s Service Level Agreement for Online Services. Depending on how long the outage lasted for your organisation, these are reported to be worth 25%, 50% or 100% of the fees for the affected service
There are a few things to be aware of:
- Credits aren’t automatic. You (or your IT provider) need to request them, and each claim is assessed on how your own environment was affected.
- There’s a deadline. Claims for the November disruption are reported to be due by 31 December 2026, so don’t leave it until the new year.
- Credits only cover your subscription fees. Indirect losses, such as missed sales, staff overtime or lost opportunities, aren’t covered.
There is very limited scope in England and Wales to challenge terms in business-to-business contracts. English and Welsh law will generally not look to interfere in contracts where, it is assumed equality of arms and equal bargaining power. It is not the job of the law to correct a bad bargain. It is of course bizarre in some ways to argue Microsoft has the same negotiating power as most small to medium-sized businesses, but ultimately that remains the current, settled position. The only challenge that can raised to terms in business-to business contracts is to argue they are unreasonable, as set out in the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. The burden is on the business arguing the term is unfair. In practice, it is highly unlikely Microsoft would have terms that do not meet the reasonableness test and would deploy significant resources to prevent a negative finding, bearing in mind how wide reaching a negative finding would be.
Therefore, you should assume that Microsoft’s standard terms would continue to apply, together with the limits on liability and the likelihood you would only be able to recover credits. Larger organisations with more bargaining power may have negotiated bespoke contracts and terms and and should have their terms reviewed to consider what they can seek to claim from Microsoft
Will Your Insurance Pay Out?
This is where most businesses are likely to have a better chance, but it depends entirely on the wording of your policy.
- Standard business interruption cover usually only applies where there has been physical damage, such as a fire or flood at your premises. An outage at a third-party provider often won’t qualify.
- Cyber insurance may help. Some policies include “system failure” or “dependent business interruption” cover, which can respond when a supplier you rely on goes down. Microsoft has said this was a technical issue rather than a cyber attack, so it’s worth checking whether your policy covers non-malicious outages, as some don’t.
- Waiting periods matter. Many policies only pay out once an outage has lasted a set number of hours. Because this one ran for close to a day, it may well have passed that threshold where shorter outages wouldn’t.
Whatever your cover, tell your insurer or broker as soon as possible. Late notification is one of the most common reasons claims run into trouble. If you believe that your insurance policy should apply, but the insurer’s reject the claim regardless, you would have grounds to complain. Depending on the size of your business, you might be able to refer the matter to the Financial Ombudsman. Otherwise, litigation remains an option.
What If Your Own Customers Want to Claim?
If the outage meant you missed a deadline or couldn’t deliver a service, you may be the one facing a complaint. Have a look at your contracts and terms and conditions for a force majeure clause, which can excuse a party from performing when something genuinely beyond its control happens.
Whether an IT outage counts depends on the exact wording. Some clauses specifically mention supplier or systems failures, while others don’t. A court may also consider whether a business could reasonably have had backup arrangements in place. If you’re in a dispute, get advice before you respond.
It’s also worth checking your contract with any IT provider or managed service provider. If they had obligations around continuity or backup that weren’t met, you may have a claim against them.
What To Do Now
- Record your losses while they’re fresh: hours lost, sales missed, overtime paid and any extra costs.
- Claim your service credits from Microsoft before the deadline.
- Notify your insurer or broker now, even if you’re unsure whether you’re covered.
- Check your policy wording for system failure or dependent business interruption cover, and any waiting periods.
- Review your contracts with customers and suppliers, particularly any force majeure clauses.
- Learn from it. Look at your business continuity plans and whether your insurance and IT contracts are fit for purpose.
If your business was affected by the outage, find out how our Commercial Litigation team can help, get in touch here.