Employment Law

17th November 2026  |  Settlement Agreements

Settlement Agreements: An Employer’s Guide

Sometimes an employment relationship has simply run its course. There may be a difficult grievance, concerns about performance, a restructure or just a recognition on both sides that things aren't working. In those situations, a settlement agreement can provide a sensible way forward without months of process and uncertainty.

That certainty is becoming increasingly valuable for employers. Changes to tribunal time limits and unfair dismissal rights mean that employment disputes can remain live for longer and, in some cases, carry greater financial risk. So when does it make sense to propose a settlement, and what should employers be thinking about before starting the conversation? Here’s what employers need to know. 

What Is a Settlement Agreement?

n simple terms, a settlement agreement is a legally binding agreement between an employer and employee, under which the employer provides an agreed package and, in return, the employee agrees not to pursue the claims covered by the agreement.  The employee must receive independent legal advice before signing, and employers will normally make a contribution towards those legal costs. 

The more difficult question is how and when to start the conversation that leads to the settlement agreement and the financial terms. A badly handled approach can make an already difficult relationship worse (and in some cases increase the cost of settlement), whereas a properly managed protected conversation can often bring matters to a conclusion surprisingly quickly. 

When Should Employers Use a Settlement Agreement?

There is no single “right” situation for proposing a settlement agreement. We regularly see them used where a working relationship has broken down, an employee has raised a grievance, performance concerns are proving difficult to resolve or a business is restructuring and implementing redundancies.  

A settlement agreement is not a substitute for good employment practice. Sometimes following the disciplinary, capability or redundancy process will be the right course of action. The issue that the employer needs to consider is whether the cost, management time and uncertainty involved in following good practice is proportionate and whether it may be better for the business to exit an employee more swiftly. 

The Benefits Of Settlement Agreements For Employers

  • Certainty. Tribunals are unpredictable. A settlement agreement replaces that risk with an agreed outcome 
  • Cost control. You negotiate the figure, rather than leaving it to a tribunal, and avoid the legal fees and management time of defending a claim (these should not be underestimated and given the backlogs in the tribunal system will likely mean issues are outstanding for 12-24 months). 
  • Confidentiality. Confidentiality and non-derogatory clauses help protect your business’s reputation (subject to the proposed new NDA rules below). 
  • Speed. Tribunal claims can take well over a year or more to resolve. Performance improvement plans can take 3-6 months. Acas guidance suggests 10 calendar days is a reasonable minimum for an employee to consider a settlement agreement, so a well-run process can conclude in weeks. 

 How The Employment Rights Act 2025 Affects Settlement Agreements

The Employment Rights Act 2025 became law on 18 December 2025 and is being introduced in stages. These are the changes most relevant to settlement: 

Change  When  What it means for employers 
Acas early conciliation extended from 6 to 12 weeks  1 December 2025  Disputes can stay open for longer 
Time limit for most tribunal claims extended from 3 to 6 months  1 October 2026  Risk lingers for longer after an employee leaves 
Unfair dismissal qualifying period cut from 2 years to 6 months  1 January 2027  Far more employees can bring a claim 
Cap on unfair dismissal compensation removed  1 January 2027  Exposure becomes uncapped (currently the lower of 52 weeks’ pay or £123,543) 
Restrictions on NDAs in harassment and discrimination cases  Expected 2027  Confidentiality clauses will need reviewing 

 For employers, the practical effect is fairly straightforward: the window in which disputes can arise is getting wider, access to unfair dismissal rights is increasing and potential exposure in some cases will be greater. That doesn’t mean employers should automatically reach for a settlement agreement, but it does make the certainty of an agreed exit considerably more attractive. 

Can a Settlement Agreement Still Include An NDA?

Yes, but with new limits. Once the rules take effect, any clause stopping a worker from speaking about harassment or discrimination, or how the employer responded to it, will be void, unless the agreement meets conditions to be set out in regulations.  

The Government’s proposals include independent advice on the NDA, written consent from the worker and a 14-day cooling-off period. These aren’t final yet, and the rules won’t apply to agreements signed before they come into force. Confidentiality provisions protecting commercially sensitive information, won’t be affected by these proposals  . 

Before You Start a Conversation

Before approaching an employee, think about what outcome you actually want. What would the alternative process involve? What claims could realistically arise? What would it cost the business in management time and legal fees to defend them? And what package would be commercially sensible to bring matters to an end? 

It is also worth taking advice before, rather than after, the first conversation. The way a settlement proposal is raised can be just as important as the terms ultimately offered. 

And settlement isn’t always the answer. There will be cases where completing a fair internal process, having a frank management conversation or using mediation is the better option. 

Thinking About Proposing a Settlement?

The best time to take advice is usually before you have the first conversation with the employee. We can help you assess the risks, decide whether settlement is the right approach and, where it is, work out how best to raise it and what a sensible package might look like. 

If you would like to discuss a particular situation or find out how we can support your business, get in touch with Daniel Wilde or contact us today. You can also find out more about our employment law services for businesses. 

Related insights

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.