By Ken Thomas, medical negligence
specialist and Welsh Lawyer of the Year at Harding Evans Solicitors
A large chunk of the money paid out by way of compensation by the
NHS in Wales every year relates to cerebral palsy claims. In the
eyes of many these are the most deserving of all medical negligence
cases.
Actual statistics of the incidence
of cerebral palsy in Wales are not readily available, however, the
cerebral palsy charity Scope suggest that across Great Britain 1
in every 400 children is affected by the condition. In other words,
every year 1,800 children are diagnosed with the condition. Here
in Gwent many families are affected by cerebral palsy. At any one
time. I am acting on behalf of several such families who have decided
to seek an investigation.
Living with cerebral palsy can be enormously difficult for both
the individual and the family. There are a multitude of support
groups/charities that can provide a wonderful source of assistance.
However, that rarely extends to financial help. This, in part, explains
why many cerebral palsy families seek a medical legal investigation
with a view to seeking compensation.
Deciding whether to pursue a potential claim can be a difficult
decision for the parents. On the downside these can be rather emotionally
draining matters. If a claim gets off the ground, it can last for
some years. Additionally, the success rates are not high –
only a minority of cases of cerebral palsy will be due to negligence
on the part of doctors delivering the baby.
However, where a claim succeeds there is a very obvious plus side.
These cases can really make a huge difference to the quality of
life of the cerebral palsy affected individual and his or her family.
Compensation will be awarded to provide professional care that would
probably not otherwise be available. Also to cover the costs of
any necessary alterations to the family home and the provision of
specialist aids and equipment.
In respect of cerebral palsy claims, the time constraints for taking
legal action are often not so pressing. If the Claimant is a child
then a claim need not be commenced until their 21st birthday. If
the cerebral palsy means the individual lacks mental capacity then
there may be no time limit at all to meet. Thus, occasionally I
am instructed to investigate claims on behalf of individuals suffering
from cerebral palsy who are well into their adulthood.
It must be said, however, that the longer a family leave it to
seek legal advice, arguably the more difficult it might be to prove
a claim. Indeed, a paper put forward by the Chief Medical Officer
last year proposed sweeping changes to the system of clinical negligence
claims. Cerebral palsy claims could be most severely affected.
Moreover, whilst currently legal aid exists for these cases we
cannot be sure that will be the case in years ahead. There is a
consultation paper due to be published by the Legal Aid Board imminently
which will consider the future funding of these cases, so if families
are thinking of seeking legal advice, now may be the time to do
so.