By Ken Thomas, medical negligence
specialist with Harding Evans Solicitors & Lawyer of the Year
(Welsh Law Awards).
We are all users of the healthcare system in this country. Every
advancing year brings with it new developments, some of them good,
some problematic. 2004 may prove to be particularly significant
for patients and their families who have suffered or will suffer
one way or another through healthcare failings.
Later this month, the nationwide
organ group litigation will at long last be tried. This will take
place at the High Court in London. The hearing will be in open Court
so that interested parties may attend and the trial is expected
to last for approximately four weeks. Three lead cases will actually
be heard, each representing the various categories of case. Nearly
70 Welsh cases are involved, some of them against hospitals in the
Gwent area.
It will be interesting to see whether many more orthopaedic patients
will follow the lead of Yvonne Watts, the lady who last year got
fed up of waiting for orthopaedic surgery in this country. She therefore
went abroad for the surgery and sought reimbursement from her local
NHS Trust who had kept her waiting such a long time. There may even
be people in the Gwent area thinking of doing so now – we
all know too well that waiting lists in Wales and especially in
our region are particularly bad and showing few signs of significant
improvement.
On a more general note, many will be interested to see how the
Government moves forward proposals to change the way clinical negligence
matters are handled. The Department of Health published a report
“Making Amends” last summer. The consultation period
in respect of that document came to an end in October.
Nearer to home, the Welsh Assembly Government in Cardiff Bay set
up a Working Party to look at clinical negligence cases in Wales
last year. The move was announced by Health Minister Jane Hutt who
indicated that she wanted there to be greater emphasis on a swifter
resolution of claims. It had been hoped that a pilot scheme could
be operational by last September but that did not materialise. Given
that at any one time there are very many patients/families pursuing
NHS complaints and claims in the Gwent area, this again is a development
that will affect a lot of people in the Gwent region.
Meanwhile, those Claimants who secure the largest awards, for instance
Cerebral Palsy child victims, may see changes to the way Courts
order the compensation to be paid out. Instead of the traditional
one off lump sum payments, Courts may begin to lean more towards
periodical payments that are paid over the lifetime of the successful
Claimant.
Legislative changes affecting mental health patients are also anticipated
in 2004. One thing is perhaps particularly likely – the number
of people coming forward to complain or claim in respect of what
they feel to have been substandard medical or dental treatment,
is likely to continue increasing.
For some years now, I have experienced a year on year increase
in the number of individuals contacting my department seeking advice
in such situations. It is likely to be many more years before we
are likely to see a significant change in that trend.