Employment law specialist Jeya
Thiruchelvam at Harding Evans Solicitors answers some key questions
on disability in the workplace.
1. What is a disability?
The legal definition of a disability is ‘a physical or mental
impairment that has a substantial and long term adverse effect on a
person’s ability to carry out day to day activities’. A disability
may be easy to identify for example, deafness, chronic arthritis,
tourette’s syndrome or less obvious such as depression or dyslexia.
A disability may include recurring or progressive conditions such as
cerebral palsy or cancer. A person with cancer, HIV or multiple
sclerosis will be regarded as a disabled person.
Basically, in order to be protected by the Disability Discrimination
Act a person must show that their condition has a ‘substantial
adverse effect’ on their daily life and its effect is long term.
This means that it has lasted or is likely to last at least 12
months. Whether a person has a disability is often an area of
dispute with employers arguing that the effects of the employee’s
condition are not sufficiently adverse to constitute a disability.
2. What about mental conditions?
A person no longer has to show that their mental condition is
‘clinically well-recognised’ in order to count as a disability. The
law used to require a person claiming that they had a mental
condition to show that their condition was recognised by a respected
body of medical opinion. This made it much harder for people with
mental health problems to satisfy the definition of a disabled
person. The effect of the removal of this requirement means it is
now easier for a person claiming that they are suffering with
depression or other mental conditions to successfully argue that
they are a disabled person.
3. What are my legal obligations towards a disabled person?
The law prohibits discrimination i.e. less favourable treatment of a
disabled person on the grounds of their disability. It also
prohibits disability related harassment or victimisation. In
addition, the law imposes a duty upon employers to make reasonable
adjustments to prevent any ‘provision, criterion or practice’
operated by an employer or ‘physical feature’ of an employer’s
premises from disadvantaging a disabled person. A failure to comply
with this duty will constitute disability discrimination.
4. Can I justify not making a reasonable adjustment?
No. If it can be show that an adjustment was reasonable then an
employer cannot justify a failure to implement it. A reasonable
adjustment may involve allocating some of a disabled person’s duties
to another person, offering an alternative job at a higher grade
without requiring a competitive interview, being absent during
working hours for rehabilitation, or changing working hours from
full-time to part-time.
5. Who will decide whether an adjustment is reasonable?
An Employment Tribunal will determine the question of whether or not
an adjustment was reasonable in the circumstances, and it is an
objective test. Accordingly, it may not be sufficient for an
employer to assert that certain adjustments were considered and
thought to be unreasonable if a Tribunal finds that there were other
adjustments that could reasonably have been made by the employer.
In deciding whether or not a specific adjustment is reasonable a
Tribunal will look at how effective the adjustments would have been;
the financial and other costs involved; the extent of disruption (if
any) it would have entailed and the resources available to the
employer. Examples of adjustments, which Tribunals have previously
held to be reasonable, include the provision of a special ‘Grahl’
chair costing £1,000 for an employee with a clubfoot, and the
discounting of disability-related absences when assessing an absence
record.
Employers must be vigilant about employee’s needs and be sure that
they properly (and regularly) assess the requirements of disabled
employees. This will extend to consulting with the disabled employee
and researching possible adjustments.
6. If I am found guilty of disability discrimination how much
will it cost me?
There is no limit to the compensation that may be awarded in
disability discrimination cases. In determining how much
compensation should be paid a Tribunal will look at the financial
losses sustained by the employee as a result of the act of
discrimination. The Tribunal will also consider the extent of the
employee’s injured feelings (if any) and order an injury to feelings
award if appropriate. Injury to feelings awards may range from £500
- £25,000 depending on the severity of the act of discrimination and
the impact that it had on the employee.